Why can’t Koreans with same last name marry?
In South Korea, it is illegal for two people with the same last name to marry. This law has its roots in Confucianism, a philosophy that strongly emphasizes family values and filial piety. The idea behind this law is to prevent marriages between people who are closely related to each other, which is believed to be detrimental to the family lineage and the social order.
The tradition of using family names dates back to ancient China, where people were assigned a surname based on their social status and ancestry. When the practice was adopted in Korea, only a few hundred family names were used, and they were reserved for the elite classes. Over time, these surnames became associated with specific regions and clans, further emphasizing the importance of family ties.
The Korean government implemented the ban on same-surname marriages in 1997, as part of a broader effort to reduce incest and promote healthy family relationships. The law applies to all Korean citizens, regardless of their religion or ethnicity.
One of the main arguments against same-surname marriages is that they can lead to genetic disorders and health problems in children. When two people with similar genetic makeup have children together, there is a higher risk of inherited diseases and disabilities.
Another reason for the ban on same-surname marriages is that they can cause confusion in genealogy records. In Korea, family lineage is traced through the male line, so when two people with the same surname marry, it can be difficult to distinguish between different branches of the family tree.
Despite these concerns, there have been instances where couples with the same last name have married and had children. In some cases, they have sought legal loopholes or special dispensations from the government in order to get married.
There are also some who argue that the ban on same-surname marriages is outdated and discriminatory. They point out that many Korean surnames are quite common, and that the risk of genetic problems is not as high as it once was.
However, proponents of the law argue that it is an important safeguard against incest and that it helps to preserve traditional family values. They also point out that there are plenty of other people to choose from when it comes to finding a spouse, so the ban is not overly restrictive.
Overall, the ban on same-surname marriages in Korea is a complex issue that touches on issues of tradition, culture, family values, and public health. As society continues to evolve and adapt to new challenges, it will be interesting to see how this law is enforced and whether it remains in place in the future.
Why can’t you marry with the same last name?
A:Marriage within the same surname is not prohibited, but it is essential to consider the relationship between the two families and any genetic disorders in their history. In India, there are various subcastes that practice intermarriage within the same surname.
Is it bad luck to marry someone with the same last name?
In certain Asian cultures, it is common for many individuals to have the same last name due to its popularity. It is believed that marrying someone with the same surname can lead to unhealthy children and bring about misfortune.
For a long time, a law prohibited marriage between individuals who had the same surname and ancestral paternal origin. However, in 1997, South Korea’s Constitutional Court deemed the law unconstitutional, and in 2005, the civil code was modified to only forbid marriage between closely related individuals.
Why don t koreans take their husbands last name?
In traditional Korean society, which was patriarchal and not modern, people placed great importance on their family values and identities. Women in Korea traditionally kept their surnames after marriage because it was believed to be an inheritance from their parents and ancestors, and therefore could not be altered.
Can 2 people with same surname get married?
If the two of you are not related within the prohibited degrees of relationship, there is no legal barrier to your marriage. This information was provided on January 16th, 2018.
Can Chinese with same last name marry?
In ancient China, marrying someone with the same surname was forbidden, but in modern China, it is allowed. The ancient Chinese law once had a rule called the “same-surname marriage prohibition,” which was eliminated in 1910, making same-surname marriage legal again.
Another reason for the ban on same-surname marriages is the potential for family conflicts and divisions. When two people with the same last name get married, they may bring together different branches of the same family tree. This can lead to power struggles, disagreements over inheritance and property rights, and other issues that can divide the family and create lasting rifts.
Moreover, the ban on same-surname marriages is also seen as a way to promote social cohesion and harmony. By encouraging people to marry outside of their immediate family, the government hopes to foster greater diversity and interconnectivity within Korean society. This is particularly important in a country that has historically been homogenous, with a strong emphasis on conformity and group identity.
However, critics of the law argue that it infringes on individual rights and freedoms. They point out that people should be free to choose whom they marry, regardless of their last name or family background. Some have even gone so far as to challenge the constitutionality of the ban, arguing that it violates basic human rights principles.
In recent years, there have been some efforts to relax the ban on same-surname marriages. In 2010, for example, the government passed a law allowing individuals with the same last name to marry if they can prove that they are not closely related. This has opened up new possibilities for couples who may have previously been unable to marry due to the law.
Overall, the issue of same-surname marriages in Korea is a complex one that touches on many different aspects of society and culture. While there are valid arguments both for and against the ban, it remains an important part of Korean law and tradition. Whether it will continue to be enforced in its current form in the years ahead remains to be seen.
